Skip to main content
SPARCS - Topic Of The Week

The Past Wasn’t Always Better

How privacy changed from “your home is your castle” to “please accept all cookies”

Jorge Manrique, a Castilian poet from the fifteenth century, wrote in one of his most famous poems dedicated to his father:

“The moments that are speeding fast
We heed not, but the past,—the past,
More highly prize.”

In today’s language, this means that we tend to think life was better in the past. We remember the good things and sometimes forget the rest.

And yes, there are things we miss: houses were cheaper, plastic was not hiding in quite so many places, and we could have a bad hair day without worrying that a photo might end up online.

But when it comes to privacy, we are not so sure that everything was better.

Today’s article idea came after watching Totally Killer, a wonderfully cheesy Halloween movie in which a teenager travels back to 1987. Watching her react to life in the 1980s made us think about how much our expectations have changed. Some things that seemed normal back then would probably make us uncomfortable today.

Remember phone books? Names, home addresses, and telephone numbers—all together in one book for other people to look up. Convenient, certainly, but also a lot of personal information made publicly available.

Of course, that does not mean people had no privacy boundaries. They had different concerns, and protections were already developing long before the internet arrived.

First stop: your home is your castle

In the United States, the Fourth Amendment, ratified in 1791, protected people against unreasonable searches and seizures by the government. It grew from an older legal idea that a person’s home is a private refuge—a castle, in effect.

This was a fairly physical understanding of privacy: your home, your papers, your belongings, and your correspondence. If someone wanted access, they generally needed a good reason and, often, a warrant.

By 1890, technology was making things more complicated, believe it or not. Lawyers Samuel Warren and Louis Brandeis were concerned about photography and newspapers exposing people’s private lives. In their article, “The Right to Privacy,” they argued for what became known as the “right to be let alone.”

That sounds familiar, doesn’t it? Someone develops a new way to collect or share information, and everyone else has to work out where the boundaries should be.

Privacy becomes a civil and consumer right

During the twentieth century, privacy started to receive more recognition. The Federal Trade Commission Act of 1914 prohibited unfair or deceptive business practices. In 1948, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights included protection against arbitrary interference with privacy, family, home, and correspondence. And in 1960, legal scholar William Prosser grouped privacy claims into four categories, covering intrusion, disclosure of private facts, false publicity, and misuse of someone’s name or likeness.

These categories addressed a world of nosy reporters, intrusive neighbors, unwanted publicity, and unauthorized advertising. They were not designed for social media, facial recognition, or apps that know where we go for coffee—but they established an important principle: privacy is not just about having secrets. It is also about having control over how information about us is collected and used.

Then came the data

The 1970s brought a major shift. Computers made it possible to collect, organize, and share enormous amounts of personal information. The Fair Credit Reporting Act of 1970 addressed the accuracy and use of consumer reports; and the Privacy Act of 1974 established rules for personal information held in certain federal agency records.

Privacy was no longer only about someone entering your home or publishing an embarrassing story. It was also about what happened to the information stored in a database: where it came from, who could see it, and whether it was correct.

From phone books to digital footprints

Fast-forward to today: those questions are still with us, but there is much more information involved. Websites can track our browsing, apps may collect our location, and information from different activities can help companies learn about our interests and habits. The phone book suddenly seems quite limited—although at least it did not know where we went after leaving the house.

We have gained protections, too. For example, the European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation, GDPR, includes rights to access and correct personal information and, in certain circumstances, have it deleted.

So, we have made progress, folks; but we have also created new privacy problems along the way. An embarrassing photo that once stayed in a family album can now be shared with hundreds of people in seconds. Information can travel farther and remain available long after we have forgotten about it.

We can ask why an app needs our location, check our sharing settings, and think before posting someone else’s photo. Organizations also have a responsibility to collect only what they need and take care of the information we give them.

Perhaps the past looks better partly because we already know how it turned out. But privacy is still something we are working on. In the meantime, we can enjoy the old movies, and be thankful that some of our questionable hairstyles never made it to social media.

On
Back to Top